A frequent claim is that Christmas borrows heavily from pagan festivals such as Saturnalia. But, then we also have to remember it falls in the same winter season Jewish festivals such as Hanukkah, a feast Jesus himself observed (John 10:22–23). Critics then argue that traditions such as gift-giving, candle lighting, or wreaths are inherently pagan and therefore inappropriate for Christians. But is this really the case? While there are historical overlaps in timing and customs, these claims often misrepresent the true origins and context of Christmas.
Jewish Roots of the Calendar
Many of the dates and symbols associated with Christmas can be traced to Jewish traditions. For instance, the story of Christ’s birth is intertwined with the Passover lamb imagery, highlighting Jesus as the sacrificial Lamb of God. Jewish texts reference Migdal Eder, the ‘tower of the flock,’ as a place associated with shepherding and messianic expectation, which many Christian scholars see as symbolically resonant with the nativity narrative.
Jewish festivals often influenced early Christian celebrations. The timing of significant events, including the Annunciation and Christ’s birth, aligns with Jewish understanding of prophetic cycles rather than merely pagan festivals. Understanding these roots demonstrates that Christmas was not arbitrarily placed to coincide with pagan holidays.
ATTENTION! I want to alert you to my Free booklet of 15+ Christmas myths! Check it out and tell me what you think. Grab yours by clicking the below link and I’ll also send you the latest iApologia updates!
15+ Myths of Christmas the Bible Doesn’t Teach
Misconceptions About Traditions
Many holiday customs that critics label as “pagan” actually have varied origins or practical explanations:
-
Gift-giving may be inspired by the Magi bringing gifts to Jesus rather than Roman Saturnalia practices.
-
Candles and lights can symbolize the arrival of the true Light of the World, Jesus Christ, rather than purely pagan sun worship.
-
Evergreen wreaths represent eternal life and hope in Christ, not necessarily a remnant of pagan ritual.
-
December 25 reflects early Christian theological reasoning, including the integral-year view linking Jesus’ conception and crucifixion, rooted in Jewish concepts of sacred time, rather than an attempt to align with pagan festivals.
These examples illustrate how Christian intent transforms cultural practices into meaningful, faith-centered celebrations.
Seasonal Cycles and Climate Influence
Historical climate data and seasonal cycles likely played a role in determining the timing of celebrations. Bethlehem’s winter weather, according to meteorological reconstructions, aligns with certain agricultural and shepherding cycles, supporting the traditional narrative of Jesus’ birth. Early Christians may have chosen dates that were both symbolically significant and practically suitable for commemorating the nativity.
Separating Origin from Meaning
It is important to recognize the logical fallacy of judging a practice solely by its origins. Even if some customs coincided with other cultural or religious traditions, their current meaning and purpose are what matter. Christmas traditions today are centered on Christ’s birth, family, generosity, and worship. The original intent of pagan festivals does not dictate the morality or significance of modern Christian celebration.
Conclusion
Christmas is a rich tapestry woven from Jewish prophetic traditions, early Christian understanding, and cultural adaptation. While some customs may overlap with other historical celebrations, these similarities do not make them inappropriate for Christians. By focusing on the meaning, symbolism, and intent behind each tradition, believers can celebrate Christmas in a way that honors Christ while appreciating the historical context.
Understanding the Jewish roots and seasonal realities of the nativity gives a clearer picture of why December 25 is celebrated and why common claims of pagan influence are often overstated. Christians can enjoy festive traditions with confidence, knowing that the calendar and its symbols point to the fulfillment of God’s promises rather than pagan origins.
I would love for you to come along with me and not miss a post! In the future, I plan on giving more resources and answers. Plus, I want to send you a Free Quick Guide why I think science points to God. I would love for you to have this Free Quick Guide and the latest posts straight to your inbox. Please grab your Free Quick Guide why I think science points to God here.
So, what did you think? Feel free to share your thoughts below!
