One of the most common objections to celebrating Christmas is that it has pagan roots. Critics argue that because December 25th coincided with Roman and other pagan festivals, Christians should avoid celebrating the holiday. This argument is often stated as, “Christmas comes from paganism, so it is inherently wrong.” While it may sound convincing, this line of reasoning is an example of a logical misstep known as the genetic fallacy.
Understanding the Genetic Fallacy
The genetic fallacy occurs when someone judges the value or morality of an idea, practice, or object solely based on its origin rather than its actual content or effects.
Here are a couple of examples:
-
Volkswagen cars were originally founded under the Nazi regime. Does that mean modern Volkswagens are “Nazi” cars? Clearly not. The company, its products, and its culture today have nothing to do with its origin.
-
Balloon animals were popularized in modern times as harmless entertainment. Some sources include colorful, anecdotal stories claiming that ancient peoples—like the Aztecs—used animal intestines in festive or ritual contexts that vaguely resemble balloon twisting. Even if one wanted to trace the art of inflating and shaping balloons back to a bizarre historical or pagan ritual (Aztecs, etc.), it would be absurd to reject today’s balloon art because of its ancient origins. (Source: BalloonHQ, Great Balloons!, 1994)
These examples show that the origin alone does not determine whether something is good, moral, or useful.
Pagan Overlap Doesn’t Make Celebration Wrong
Even if some Christmas customs overlapped with pagan festivals, this does not automatically make the celebration sinful. Many cultural practices, including food, decorations, and holiday traditions, may have roots outside of Christianity. However, Christians are free to engage in activities that are not inherently sinful, regardless of historical origin.
The Bible provides guidance for such freedom. Romans 13 reminds believers to honor cultural structures and authorities, while 1 Corinthians 8 and 1 Corinthians 10 discuss how Christians may partake in practices as long as they do not violate conscience or promote idolatry. These passages emphasize wisdom and discernment rather than rejecting every cultural element because of historical associations.
ATTENTION! I want to alert you to my Free booklet of 15+ Christmas myths! Check it out and tell me what you think. Grab yours by clicking the below link and I’ll also send you the latest iApologia updates!
15+ Myths of Christmas the Bible Doesn’t Teach
Applying the Principle to Christmas
In practical terms, celebrating Christmas today focuses on remembering Christ’s birth, sharing with family and neighbors, and giving to others. Even if certain elements of the holiday coincided with pagan customs in the past, the intent and meaning now are centered on Christ. Festive food, decorations, and symbols may have historical overlap with non-Christian practices, but they are not inherently evil (and often can be dropped in Christmas celebrations!). What matters is the purpose behind the celebration and the values it promotes.
Conclusion
The argument that Christmas is wrong because of pagan origins is an example of the genetic fallacy. Historical overlap does not make a practice immoral. Christians have freedom to celebrate cultural and religious practices as long as they do not compromise conscience or contradict God’s commands. Christmas can be a time to honor Christ, strengthen family bonds, and share generosity, regardless of where certain customs originated. Understanding the difference between origin and meaning allows believers to celebrate responsibly and joyfully—just as we can enjoy balloon animals or drive a Volkswagen today without worrying about their past.
I would love for you to come along with me and not miss a post! In the future, I plan on giving more resources and answers. Plus, I want to send you a Free Quick Guide why I think science points to God. I would love for you to have this Free Quick Guide and the latest posts straight to your inbox. Please grab your Free Quick Guide why I think science points to God here.
So, what did you think? Feel free to share your thoughts below!
