A frequent objection raised by skeptics of December 25 as Jesus’ birth date concerns the shepherds in the fields. Many argue that winter in Bethlehem would be too cold for shepherds to watch their flocks overnight. Historical climate data and traditional shepherding practices, however, show that this objection is based on misconceptions.
Bethlehem’s Winter Climate: Mild, Not Harsh
Bethlehem, located in the Judean hills about six miles south of Jerusalem, experiences a Mediterranean climate. Winter nights are cool but not frigid, with average lows typically between 40 and 45 degrees Fahrenheit. While occasional rain or frost may occur, snow is extremely rare.
Sheep and goats are hardy animals accustomed to outdoor conditions, and ancient shepherds were trained to care for them year-round.
Historical Shepherding Practices
Shepherds frequently stayed with their flocks overnight, even in winter months, because:
-
Constant vigilance was necessary to protect flocks from predators, theft, and disease.
-
Night watches were a normal part of pastoral life in Judea.
-
The biblical narrative in Luke 2:8—“shepherds living out in the fields, keeping watch over their flock by night”—aligns with these practices.
While we lack archaeological evidence of specific winter enclosures near Bethlehem, natural terrain or temporary windbreaks would have provided sufficient shelter.
ATTENTION! I want to alert you to my Free booklet of 15+ Christmas myths! Check it out and tell me what you think. Grab yours by clicking the below link and I’ll also send you the latest iApologia updates!
15+ Myths of Christmas the Bible Doesn’t Teach
Geography and Practical Considerations
Bethlehem is surrounded by rolling hills and open pastures. These features allowed shepherds to:
-
Monitor their flocks while remaining protected from wind or rain.
-
Take advantage of natural grazing areas and vantage points.
-
Conduct necessary night watches safely, even in winter, against predators like wolves and jackals.
Modern Analogs
Contemporary Mediterranean shepherding supports the historical feasibility of winter night watches:
-
Shepherds in rural Israel, Greece, and southern Italy often keep animals outdoors year-round.
-
While modern shelters exist, the primary practice of night watches persists, confirming that ancient shepherding methods were practical and sustainable.
Implications for Understanding Christmas
Recognizing Bethlehem’s climate and shepherding practices removes a common objection to December 25 as a plausible date for Jesus’ birth. Critics who dismiss the nativity story as historically impossible often overlook:
-
The mild winter conditions.
-
The practical realities of shepherding in Judea.
While this does not establish the exact date of Jesus’ birth, it demonstrates that shepherds in the fields at night during winter were historically reasonable.
Conclusion
The objection that shepherds could not have been outdoors in winter does not hold up under scrutiny. Bethlehem’s winter temperatures were mild, the terrain supported grazing and night watches, and pastoral practices required shepherds to stay with their flocks. Luke’s account of shepherds keeping watch at night is consistent with these realities. Christians can celebrate the nativity with confidence, knowing the biblical depiction of shepherds’ night watches is both plausible and historically sound.
I would love for you to come along with me and not miss a post! In the future, I plan on giving more resources and answers. Plus, I want to send you a Free Quick Guide why I think science points to God. I would love for you to have this Free Quick Guide and the latest posts straight to your inbox. Please grab your Free Quick Guide why I think science points to God here.
So, what did you think? Feel free to share your thoughts below!
